OUR Menu
Where Flavor And Family Meet
At Handlebar Cafe in Butler, a cozy vibe meets Italian culinary tradition. Dive into freshly made pizzas and pastas, crafted with love and family recipes.
Got a birthday party, rehearsal dinner, corporate or other event coming up? We're a great option for your gathering! Inquire today and let us know how we can make your special occasion perfect!
Cater your birthday party, holiday party, corporate events, wedding festivities and more!
Join us on Mother's Day and treat your mom to a delicious meal!
We recommend making a reservation ahead of time. Book your table today!
Order your favorite dishes in seconds!
Cinco De Mayo - Grab your best fiesta hat and join us for Cinco de Mayo!
Book TableGraduation Parties - Let us help you make this graduation season special if you are honoring any new graduates.
Book your partyAt Handlebar Cafe in Butler, a cozy vibe meets Italian culinary tradition. Dive into freshly made pizzas and pastas, crafted with love and family recipes.
Bring exceptional Italian cuisine to your events with our catering service. From intimate gatherings to big celebrations, our curated menu creates a delightful experience for every occasion.
Celebrate with us in style, where each event is crafted to your unique vision. Relax and immerse yourself in the joy of the moment while we take care of every detail seamlessly.
Enjoy the convenience of our delicious dishes delivered straight to your door. With just a few clicks, savor your favorite Italian flavors from home.
We got take out for the first time yesterday, and it was delicious! We got the Chicago deep dish, Buffalo chicken pizza, and the pretzel rods! All three were amazing! We will definitely be back! I would recommend to anyone to come here!!
Food is always great, I've never once had bad food or service from here. They have great IPA's and beers on tap, my favorite is the just cloudy IPA, it is so good. This place is a gem and I hope they have many years of success here in my hometown of Saxonburg!
Every pizza I try at Handlebar is always tasty! The service is always phenomenal & the pub style atmosphere is cozy & relaxed. They also have a great selection of local wines & beer. My favorite pizza is the white pizza!
Terrific food! Chicago deep dish is the most authentic around. The garlic knots and fresh chips are our favorite apps. Love the Sweet Hot Honey pizza!!! We mostly order online for delivery and the service is always great and delivery is at the given time.
We stopped by to check the place out. Nice atmosphere. Food was as good as the pictures. I enjoyed the chopped salad (1/2) and we shared a deep dish pie (pepperoni, sausage and banana peppers). A couple beers too. Was good. Recommend if you're in the area.
Book your spot and enjoy a delightful dining experience in a cozy setting. Perfect for family gatherings or a night out, reserving your table is quick and easy.
Reserve